Skip to main content

Table 5 Appraisal of the appropriateness of acupuncture treatment

From: The reporting quality of acupuncture-related traumatic adverse events: a systematic review of case studies in Korea

Study ID (author, year)

Appropriateness of acupuncture treatment*

Bahn (1999) [34]

Inappropriate

Chun (2014) [19]

Unclear

Chung (2008) [16]

Unclear

Chung (2016) [40]

Unclear

Chung (2020) [33]

Unclear

Ha (2009) [17]

Unclear

Her (2013) [14]

Inappropriate

Hong (2006) [24]

Unclear

Hwang (2008) [26]

Unclear

Jeon (2004) [22]

Unclear

Kang (2013) [30]

Inappropriate

Koo (2022) [21]

Unclear

Kim (2006) [25]

Unclear

Kim (2009) [27]

Unclear

Kim (2011) [36]

Unclear

Kim (2011) [18]

Unclear

Kim (2011) [37]

Unclear

Lee (2001) [13]

Unclear

Lee (2005) [23]

Unclear

Lee (2008) [35]

Unclear

Lee (2020) [39]

Inappropriate

Moon (2013a) [29]

Unclear

Moon (2013b) [38]

Inappropriate

Park (2013) [28]

Unclear

Park (2019) [31]

Unclear

Sung (2016) [15]

Inappropriate

 

Woo (2020) [32]

Unclear

 

Yeo (2021) [20]

Unclear

 
  1. *Appropriate, if none of the acupuncture procedure could be a probable cause for the events; Inappropriate, if any process of acupuncture practice might be the probable cause for the events; Unclear, if we could not determine the causality due to the lack of detailed description of the acupuncture treatment