Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of included studies(1)

From: Effect of acupuncture combined with rehabilitation training on sensory impairment of patients with stroke: a network meta-analysis

 

Study

Intervention

Number of patients (T/C)

Intervention period

Relevant outcomes

  

T

C

   

1

Ma Huimin 2022

J

K

22(11/11)

14days

â‘ 

2

Jia Xiaonan 2022

B

K

107(54/53)

30days

â‘¡

3

Wang Wei 2022

C

K

67(34/33)

60days

â‘¡

4

Li Hongying 2022

A

K

76(38/38)

90days

â‘¡

5

Li Lingling 2021

G

K

66(33/33)

60days

â‘ 

6

Chen Yinjianzi 2021

G

K

102(51/51)

14days

â‘ â‘¡â‘¢

7

Ye Zhong 2021

A

K

40(20/20)

30days

â‘ 

8

Li Yawei 2021

D

K

120(60/60)

30days

â‘¡

9

Lv Sunsun 2021

D

K

80(40/40)

28days

â‘ 

10

Wu Suqing 2021

B

K

440(220/220)

56days

â‘ 

11

Wu Yuping 2021

H

K

100(50/50)

14days

â‘¡

12

Bai Xiaohui 2021

A

K

78(39/39)

28days

â‘¡

13

Wang Pan 2021

D

K

90(45/45)

20days

â‘¡â‘¢

14

Hua Bin 2021

A

K

40(20/20)

42days

â‘¡

15

Yan Li 2020

A

K

156(78/78)

56days

â‘ 

16

Zhao Wenjin 2018

C

K

80(40/40)

84days

â‘¡â‘¢

17

Dong Gang 2017

F

K

89(45/44)

60days

â‘ â‘¡â‘¢

18

Feng Xiaodong 2015

I

K

60(30/30)

28days

â‘ 

19

Wang Hongbin 2015

A

K

104(52/52)

14days

â‘¡â‘¢

20

Xiong Peifang 2015

I

K

82(41/41)

28days

â‘ â‘¡

  1. Abbreviation: T Treatment groupm, C Control group
  2. â‘ Modified Barthel Index (MBI) â‘¡The Scores of Numbness Symptom.â‘¢The Sensory Disturbance Scores
  3. A: acupuncture plus rehabilitation, B: acupuncture plus massage plus rehabilitation, C: acupuncture plus oral Chinese medicine plus rehabilitation, D: warm needing plus rehabilitation, E: acupoint injection plus oral Chinese medicine plus rehabilitation, F: acupoint injection plus rehabilitation, G: electro-acupuncture plus rehabilitation, H: acupuncture plus herbal fomentation plus rehabilitation, I: blood-letting puncture plus rehabilitation, J: fire needing plus rehabilitation, K: rehabilitation