Table 3 Risk of bias of included studies (Quantitative approaches)
From: Mind-body practices for people living with HIV: a systematic scoping review
Project identifier | Selection | Performance | Detection | Attrition | Reporting | Other |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tai Chi (n = 3) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [32] | HR | HR | HR | HR | UR | LR |
RCT | ||||||
 [30] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [31] | LR | HR | LR | LR | LR | LR |
Yoga (n = 9) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [35] | HR | HR | HR | UR | LR | LR |
 [36] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
 [37] | HR | HR | HR | UR | LR | LR |
RCT | ||||||
 [38] | LR | HR | UR | HR | UR | LR |
 [20] | UR | HR | UR | UR | LR | LR |
 [39] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [40] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [41] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [42] | LR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
Meditation (n = 17) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [43] | HR | HR | HR | UR | UR | UR |
 [44] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
 [45] | HR | HR | HR | UR | LR | LR |
 [46] | HR | HR | HR | UR | LR | LR |
 [47] | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR | LR |
 [48] | HR | HR | HR | UR | UR | UR |
 [49] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
 [50] | HR | HR | HR | LR | HR | LR |
 [51] | HR | HR | UR | UR | LR | LR |
RCT | ||||||
 [52] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [53] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [54] | LR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [55] | UR | HR | LR | UR | LR | LR |
 [56] | LR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
 [57] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [58] | LR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
PMR = (9) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [59] | HR | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR |
 [60] | HR | HR | HR | LR | UR | LR |
 [61] | HR | HR | HR | UR | UR | UR |
 [62] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | UR |
RCT | ||||||
 [63] | UR | HR | UR | UR | LR | LR |
 [64] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [65] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [66] | UR | HR | UR | UR | HR | UR |
 [67] | UR | HR | UR | UR | LR | LR |
Hypnosis (n = 8) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [68] | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR | LR |
 [69] | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR | LR |
 [70] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | HR |
 [71] | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR | LR |
 [72] | HR | HR | UR | UR | LR | LR |
 [73] | LR | HR | LR | HR | LR | LR |
RCT | ||||||
 [74] | HR | HR | LR | HR | LR | HR |
 [75] | UR | HR | UR | UR | UR | UR |
Guided imagery (n = 6) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [76] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
 [77] | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR | LR |
 [78] | LR | HR | UR | UR | LR | LR |
RCT | ||||||
 [79] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [80] | LR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [81] | LR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
Autogenic training (n = 1) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [82] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
Breathing exercise (n = 1) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [83] | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR | LR |
Neurofeedback (n = 1) | ||||||
RCT | ||||||
 [84] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
Combination of least three relaxation techniques (n = 20) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [85] | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR | LR |
 [86] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
 [87] | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR | LR |
 [88] | HR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [89] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
 [90] | LR | UR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
RCT | ||||||
 [91] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [92] | UR | UR | UR | UR | UR | UR |
 [93] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [94] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [95] | LR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [96] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [97] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [98] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [99] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [100] | LR | HR | LR | LR | LR | LR |
 [101] | LR | LR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [102] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [103] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [104] | LR | LR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
Unspecified relaxation (n = 8) | ||||||
NRCT | ||||||
 [105] | HR | HR | HR | HR | LR | LR |
 [106] | UR | UR | UR | UR | LR | LR |
RCT | ||||||
 [107] | UR | HR | UR | UR | UR | LR |
 [108] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [109] | UR | HR | UR | UR | LR | LR |
 [110] | UR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |
 [111] | UR | HR | UR | LR | LR | LR |
 [112] | HR | HR | UR | HR | LR | LR |