- Research article
- Open Access
- Open Peer Review
Optimizing acupuncture treatment for dry eye syndrome: a systematic review
BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicinevolume 18, Article number: 145 (2018)
In a former meta-analysis review, acupuncture was considered a potentially effective treatment for dry eye syndrome (DES), but there were heterogeneities among the outcomes. We updated the meta-analysis and conducted subgroup analysis to reduce the heterogeneity and suggest the most effective acupuncture method based on clinical trials.
We searched for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in 10 databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTAL, AMED, SCOPUS, CNKI, Wangfang database, Oriental Medicine Advanced Searching Integrated System (OASIS), Koreamed, J-stage) and searched by hand to compare the effects of acupuncture and artificial tears (AT). We also conducted subgroup analysis by (1) method of intervention (acupuncture only or acupuncture plus AT), (2) intervention frequency (less than 3 times a week or more than 3 times a week), (3) period of treatment (less than 4 weeks or more than 4 weeks), and (4) acupoints (BL1, BL2, ST1, ST2, TE23, Ex-HN5). The Bucher method was used for subgroup comparisons.
Nineteen studies with 1126 patients were included. Significant improvements on the Schirmer test (weighted mean difference[WMD], 2.14; 95% confidence interval[CI], 0.93 to 3.34; p = 0.0005) and break up time (BUT) (WMD, 0.98; 95% CI, 0.79 to 1.18; p < 0.00001) were reported. In the subgroup analysis, acupuncture plus AT treatment had a weaker effect in BUT but a stronger effect on the Schirmer test and a better overall effect than acupuncture alone. For treatment duration, treatment longer than 1 month was more effective than shorter treatment. With regard to treatment frequency, treatment less than three times a week was more effective than more frequent treatment. In the acupoint analysis, acupuncture treatment including the BL2 and ST1 acupoints was less effective than treatment that did not include them. None of those factors reduced the heterogeneity.
Acupuncture was more effective than AT in treating DES but showed high heterogeneity. Intervention differences did not influence the heterogeneity.
Dry eye syndrome (DES) is a multifactorial disease of the tears and ocular surface that can result in ocular discomfort and visual impairment . In recent years, the geriatric proportion of the overall population has increased, and factors causing eye fatigue have diversified (e.g., excessive use of computers or smartphones). In 2011, the prevalence of DES in South Korea was 8.0% . According to statistics from the National Health Insurance Service in South Korea, the prevalence of DES is increasing continuously “(http://opendata.hira.or.kr/home.do)”.
Acupuncture can alleviate DES. Some systematic reviews showed that acupuncture is effective for DES [3,4,5]. However, heterogeneous results from various interventions made it difficult to draw clear conclusions. Each study used different acupoints, durations, and frequencies. An individual treatment strategy according to patient condition is ideal. However, an individual treatment strategy depends on each clinician’s subjective experience, which indicates low effectiveness of novice practitioners. An adequate acupuncture dose is needed to standardize and optimize its effects. Also, some standards are required to increase the reproducibility of results. There have been some attempts to define adequate acupuncture treatments for other diseases [6, 7].
Our aim in this study was to evaluate the efficacy of acupuncture using the latest research and to suggest a standard acupuncture treatment for patients with DES, including acupoints, number of sessions, and treatment duration. Therefore, we conducted a systematic review of published acupuncture treatments for DES and analyzed the factors that influence therapeutic effectiveness.
We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTAL, AMED, SCOPUS, CNKI, the Wangfang database, the Oriental Medicine Advanced Searching Integrated System (OASIS), Koreamed, and J-stage and conducted manual searches for potentially relevant articles published through July 2017. (CNKI and Wangfang are Chinese databases. OASIS and Koreamed are Korean databases. J-stage is a Japanese database.) The search terms used were ‘acupuncture’ AND (‘dry eye’ OR ‘xerophthalmia’ OR ‘keratoconjunctivitis sicca’). In the Chinese databases (CNKI, Wangfang database), we used the Chinese terms (‘干眼’ AND ‘针’). There were no limits with regard to publications, other than language limits of English, Chinese, or Korean.
The specific inclusion criteria were as follows: (1) clinical trial for DES patients; (2) use of acupuncture or an applied form (e.g., electroacupuncture, pyonex); (3) control group that received appropriate placebo or artificial tears (AT); (4) outcomes included Schirmer’s test (ST), break up time test (BUT), or corneal fluorescein staining (CFS); (5) randomized controlled trials (RCT); and (6) full text available. We excluded (1) studies that included Sjögren syndrome patients and (2) interventions combined with other treatments (e.g., herbal medicine, moxibustion). Two researchers (MHK and SHK) carried out the study selection independently and discussed their differences.
Data extraction and assessment of risk of bias
Three independent reviewers (MHK, BHK and SHK) read all selected articles. We extracted publication data, participant information, intervention regime (sites, duration, and frequency), outcome measures, and drop-outs. After extraction, we assessed the risk of bias using the Cochrane Collaboration tool .
For our meta-analysis of similar treatment interventions, we used the statistical software provided by the Cochrane Collaboration (RevMan 5.3). The estimated effect of the data was calculated using the weighted mean difference (WMD) and confidence interval (CI). The Q-test or χ2 was used to evaluate heterogeneity . When the compared populations were homogeneous (Q-test p > 0.1), we used the fixed-effect model; when they were heterogeneous (p < 0.1), we used the random-effect model. We also performed a sensitivity analysis. Each study was sequentially excluded from the meta-analysis, and the sensitivity was determined from the corresponding heterogeneity results. Funnel plot was conducted for detecting publication bias.
In our subgroup analysis, we used the standard mean difference (SMD) in BUT and ST values to evaluate the overall effects according to the Bucher method. This is one of the most suitable indirect comparisons for RCTs. We applied this method, as there were no direct comparative trials and an indirect method can provide useful information for optimization. This method is supposed that treatments A and C are compared in one RCT and treatments B and C are compared in another RCT, the indirect comparison of A and B is adjusted according to C (common comparator). This method assumes that indirect evidence is consistent with a direct comparison .
We analyzed the interventions as follows: (1) method of intervention (acupuncture only or acupuncture plus AT), (2) intervention frequency (less than 3 times a week or more than 3 times a week), (3) treatment duration (less than 4 weeks or more than 4 weeks), and (4) acupoints (BL1, BL2, ST1, ST2, TE23, Ex-HN5). Selection of the acupoints frequently used in clinical trials is explained in a previous study .
We identified 462 articles of potential relevance. Screening the titles and abstracts yielded 36 studies. After reviewing the full texts, we selected 19 studies. Studies were excluded for the following reasons: (1) not an RCT (n = 4); (2) outcomes did not include ST, BUT, or CFS (n = 4); (3) acupuncture was part of a complex intervention (n = 4); (4) comments (n = 3); (5) inadequate data (n = 1); (6) Sjögren syndrome patients were included as participants (n = 1). The procedure is summarized in Fig. 1.
We included 19 studies and 1126 subjects in this review. Fourteen studies [12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25] compared manual acupuncture with AT. One study  used sham acupuncture as a control group. Four studies [27,28,29,30] used an applied form of acupuncture (two studies used electroacupuncture, and two used pyonex). Fifteen of the studies [13, 14, 16,17,18,19, 21,22,23,24,25, 27,28,29,30] were conducted in China. The study descriptions are given in Tables 1 and 2.
Risk of bias assessment
In 8 studies [14, 16, 19,20,21, 23, 26, 28], the investigators described a method of random sequence generation (random number table, coin tossing, envelope shuffling, and using a computerized random-number generator). Only 4 studies [16, 20, 26, 28] conducted allocation concealment, and 4 studies [15, 19, 20, 28] used assessor blinding. Drop rates and reasons were reported in 6 studies [19, 20, 23, 26, 28]. Two studies used a study protocol [20, 26]. In 4 studies, we suspected bias: two studies [16, 17] had significant differences between the treatment and control groups at baseline without revision or explanation; in the other two studies, the duration differed between the treatment and control groups [13, 14]. Figure 2 summarizes the risk of bias assessment. Furthermore, there was no evidence of significant publication bias by inspection of the funnel plots.
Meta-analysis between manual acupuncture and artificial tears
In this meta-analysis, we used the results of 11 of 14 studies that recorded both BUT and ST. We excluded Nepp  and Gong  because the former showed only graph and the later showed change value. We also excluded Zhang  through our sensitivity analysis because it presented a heterogeneous result that did not seem to be due to acupuncture. We did not consider CFS results in this meta-analysis because two studies used a dichotomous scale [13, 14], three used a continuous scale [18, 22, 23], and they used different methods of measuring.
In the BUT results, a significant difference was shown between groups (WMD, 0.92; 95% CI, 0.60 to 1.25; p < 0.00001), but the heterogeneity was high (I2 = 62%; P = 0.003). The studies that used an acupuncture plus AT intervention did not show a mean difference (p = 0.21), but the studies that used only acupuncture did show a significant difference (p < 0.00001), including a subgroup difference(p = 0.04) (Fig. 3).
The ST results also showed a significant difference between manual acupuncture and AT (WMD, 1.98; 95% CI, 0.62 to 3.35; p = 0.004), though again, the heterogeneity of the effect was high (I2 = 96%; P < 0.00001). Each of the two subgroups showed significant differences within the groups, but we did not find differences between the subgroups. (WMD, 1.65; 95% CI, 0.37 to 2.92 versus WMD, 2.93; 95% CI, 0.32 to 5.55; p = 0.39) (Fig. 4).
In treatment duration and frequency, long-term (more than 1 month) and less frequent (less than 3 times a week) treatments were more effective than short-term or intensive treatments, but the difference was not significant. (Table 3).
In acupoint differences, regimes including the BL2 or ST1 acupoints showed significantly weaker effects than regimes that did not include them (BL2; SMD, 0.35 vs 0.81; p = 0.03, ST1, SMD, 0.28 vs 0.91; p = 0.002). There were no significantly different values for other acupoints (BL1, TE23, ST2, Ex-HN5, Table 3).
One study compared verum acupuncture with sham acupuncture . In this study, the sham acupuncture was applied to non-acupoints (peri-acupoints). There were no significantly different outcomes between the verum and sham acupuncture groups. Two studies used electroacupuncture: Liu et al. compared electroacupuncture with AT and found significant ST and BUT effects in the experimental group ; Guo et al. compared electroacupuncture at BL1 with manual acupuncture and found minor effects in eye symptoms and ST in the intervention group . Two studies investigated pyonex: one study compared pyonex with manual acupuncture , and the other compared it with AT and found limited improvements compared with the control group  (Table 2).
Some previous systematic reviews have considered the effects of acupuncture in DES [3,4,5]. In this study, we focused on subgroup analysis to solidify the results and suggest an effective method of acupuncture treatment. We excluded one study  for heterogeneity because it showed a unique change and used an unusual intervention: the practitioners treated the superior/inferior lacrimal punctum and proceeded horizontally 5-15 mm through the lacrimal canaliculi, similar to lacrimal probing. This effect focused on penetration, so it was difficult to regard its effects as resulting purely from the acupuncture.
As in former studies, heterogeneity in the effects of manual acupuncture was high; we conducted subgroup analysis for method of intervention, treatment duration, frequency, and acupoints. However, accounting for those factors did not lower the heterogeneity. A high risk of bias can cause heterogeneity. Information about the randomization method, number of and reason for drop outs, statistical analysis methods, and blinding outcome analysis is essential to decrease the risk of bias in a clinical study. However, several studies did not include this data.
Acupuncture combined with AT treatment had a weaker effect on BUT score but a stronger effect on ST score and a better overall effect than acupuncture treatment alone. ST evaluates tear production, and BUT evaluates tear film stabilization. Acupuncture plus AT thus showed a synergetic effect in tear production but not in tear stabilization. Manual acupuncture affected the protein composition in tears [19, 25], but combining with AT, there was no synergetic effect, which clinicians should consider when planning treatments for individual patients.
With regard to duration and frequency, a long period of treatment (more than 1 month) is preferable to a short period (less than 1 month), but frequent treatment does not guarantee better effects. Three times a week showed better effectiveness than 5–6 times a week. Recovery time might be needed to produce optimal effects. Harris et al. said that the effects of acupuncture are dose dependent . Experts recommend at least twice a week to obtain a proper effect . Therefore, 2–3 times a week could be an optimal frequency to maximize the effects.
Most studies we selected included periorbital acupoints. Thus, the effects of acupuncture in DES are mostly local. According to Shin et al. , the effect of acupuncture on DES occurs by dilating blood vessels and increasing the supply of neuropeptides (e.g., Calcitonin gene related peptide). However, our analysis implied positional specificity. The studies that included points BL2 and ST1 were less effective than those that did not include those points. This could be related to the analgesic effect of acupuncture. ST1 is located between the eyeball and the infraorbital ridge, directly below the pupil, and BL2 is located at the medial end of the eyebrow. They are thus near the supraorbital nerve block and infraorbital nerve block sites. Those two nerves innervate the conjunctiva, and decreased conjunctiva sensitivity decreases tear production. Therefore, clinicians should select acupoints according to patient symptoms.
Some of the included studies also considered electroacupuncture and pyonex. Electroacupuncture is commonly considered to be a stronger stimulus than acupuncture. Pyonex is a kind of patch acupuncture known for its long retention. However, only a few studies used those interventions, and they had many limitations in design. Therefore, we did not evaluate the effects of electroacupuncture and pyonex in DES. Well-designed studies are needed to evaluate their effects.
Additionally, Female sex is a risk factor in DES . In our study, there were also female subjects than male subjects. Sex hormone (e.g., androgen) can be a factor in explaining this result. Androgen have a positive effect as anti-inflammatory effect on DES [34, 35]. Acupuncture may modulate sex hormone . However, there was no study focusing on this point. Further study concerning about the hormone is needed to clarify the mechanism of acupuncture.
Our study has several limitations. We conducted indirect comparisons and used the Bucher method to avoid some biases. Indirect comparisons require more caution in interpretation than direct comparisons . Moreover, they require homogeneity for validity. However, the analyzed studies were so heterogeneous in their subgroups that bias was almost inevitable. Nonetheless, even though an indirect analysis is less reliable than a direct comparison, it can allow doctors to make treatment plans for patients and defines a method to improve treatment effects and reproducibility.
Furthermore, some of the reviewed studies have significant weak points. Some studies that we analyzed did not report information necessary to discern the risk of bias. Comparing acupuncture with AT is an open label trial. Therefore, strict randomization, allocation concealment, and blinding of outcome assessments are needed to avoid bias. Furthermore, only two studies conducted [19, 20] follow-up evaluations. Although manual acupuncture was more effective than AT, AT is more convenient to use. Subjects who want to receive acupuncture treatment must go to a clinic and spend time there, which is not necessary for AT treatment. Therefore, acupuncture must have strengths that outweigh the convenience of AT. One study suggested that acupuncture effects last longer than AT . The disadvantage of typical AT is its short persistence. Further studies should include follow-up evaluations to strengthen this conclusion.
Acupuncture is more effective than AT in DES. Treatment duration of more than 1 month and treatment frequency less than 3 times a week could be more effective than shorter or more frequent treatments. Use of the BL2 and ST1 acupoints can reduce the overall effectiveness of acupuncture for DES. Other acupuncture treatments (electroacupuncture, pyonex) could be applicable, but there are not yet enough studies to evaluate their effects.
Corneal fluorescein staining
Dry eye syndrome
Randomized controlled trials
The definition and classification of dry eye disease: report of the Definition and Classification Subcommittee of the International Dry Eye WorkShop (2007). The ocular surface. 2007;5:75–92.
Ahn JM, Lee SH, Rim THT, Park RJ, Yang HS, Kim TI, et al. Prevalence of and risk factors associated with dry eye: the Korea National Health and nutrition examination survey 2010–2011. Am J Ophthalmol. 2014;158:1205–1214.e7.
Lee MS, Shin B, Choi T, Ernst E. Acupuncture for treating dry eye: a systematic review. Acta Ophthalmol. 2011;89:101–6.
Ba J, Wu Y, Li Y, Xu D, Zhu W, Yu J. Updated meta-analysis of acupuncture for treating dry eye. Med Acupunct. 2013;25:317–27.
Yang L, Yang Z, Yu H, Song H. Acupuncture therapy is more effective than artificial tears for dry eye syndrome: evidence based on a meta-analysis. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2015;2015:143858.
Armour M, Smith CA. Treating primary dysmenorrhoea with acupuncture: a narrative review of the relationship between acupuncture “dose” and menstrual pain outcomes. Acupunct Med: J British Med Acupunct Soc. 2016;34:416–24.
Vas J, White A. Evidence from RCTs on optimal acupuncture treatment for knee osteoarthritis--an exploratory review. Acupuncture in medicine : journal of the British medical acupuncture society. British Med Acupunct Soc. 2007;25:29–35.
Higgins JP, Green S. Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0. Collaboration. TC, editor. Wiley; 2011. http://handbook-5-1.cochrane.org/. Accessed Aug 2017.
Higgins JPT, Thompson SG. Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med. 2002;21:1539–58.
Bucher HC, Guyatt GH, Griffith LE, Walter SD. The results of direct and indirect treatment comparisons in meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. J Clin Epidemiol. 1997;50:683–91.
Med S, Jiaojiao W, Weiping G. Literature analysis involving dry eye managed by Chinese medicine. China J Chin Ophthalmol. 2016;26:269–73.
Nepp J, Wedrich A, Akramian J, Derbolav A, Mudrich C, Ries E, et al. Dry eye treatment with acupuncture. A prospective, randomized, double-masked study. Advances in experimental medicine and biology. J Nepp, University eye Clinic of Vienna, Austria. 1998;438:1011–6.
He H, Wang Z, Hu H, Liu R. Effect of acupuncture on lacrimal film of Xeroma patients. J Nanjing TCM Univ. 2004;20:158–9.
Wang Z-L, He H-Q, Huang D, Shi C-G. Effect of integral syndrome differentiation acupuncture on the tear film stability in the patient of xerophthalmia. Chin Acupunct Moxibustion. 2005;25:460–3.
Tseng K, Liu H, Tso K, Woung L, Su Y, Lin J. A clinical study of acupuncture and SSP (silver spike point) electro-therapy for dry eye syndrome. Am J Chin Med. 2006;34:197–206.
Zhang C, Zhang J, Deng S. Acupuncture treatment for the treatment of 30 cases of dry eye syndrome. Henan Tradit chin Medicine. 2009;29:895–6.
Gong L, Sun X, Chapin WJ. Clinical curative effect of acupuncture therapy on Xerophthalmia. Am J Chin Med. 2010;38:651–9.
Gao W, Liu M, Zhang Y. Observation on therapeutic effect of dry eye syndrome treated with acupuncture on the acupoints around the eyes. Chinese acupuncture & moxibustion. WP Gao, eye department, first affiliated clinical medical College of Nanjing University of TCM, Nanjing 210029, China. 2010;30:478–80.
Shi J, Miao W. Effects of acupuncture on lactoferrin content in tears and tear secretion in patients suffering from dry eyes: a randomized controlled trial. J Chin Integr Med. 2012;10:1003–8.
Kim T, Kang J, Kim K, Kang K, Shin M, Jung S, et al. Acupuncture for the treatment of dry eye: a multicenter randomised controlled trial with active comparison intervention (artificial teardrops). Rosenbaum JT, editor. PLoS One 2012;7:e36638.
Nan H Ping. Clinical observation of 60 cases of dry eye syndrome by the treatment of eye acupuncture combining the artificial tears. Boading: Hubei university of Chin Med; 2014.
Zhang D, Xing Y, Song X, Wang Z. Therapeutic observation of hair needle therapy for dry eye syndrome. Shanghai J Acupunct-moxibustion. 2015;34:1195–7.
Ni W, Li J, Ji Q, Song Y, Liu B, Wang G, et al. Clinical efficacy on xerosis conjunctivitis of liver and kidney yin deficiency treated with SHI’s acupuncture manipulation. Chin Acupunct Moxibustion. 2016;36:364–8.
Chao Y. The clinical observations on efficacy of a qi-absorption needling technique in treating dry eye syndromes. Dalian: Dalian Medical University; 2016.
Liu Q, Liu J, Ren C, Cai W, Wei Q, Song Y, et al. Proteomic analysis of tears following acupuncture treatment for menopausal dry eye disease by two-dimensional nano-liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry. International journal of Nanomedicine. J Yu, Department of Ophthalmology, shanghai tenth People’s hospital, shanghai, China. 2017;12:1663–71.
Shin M, Kim J, Lee M, Kim K, Choi J, Kang K, et al. Acupuncture for treating dry eye: a randomized placebo-controlled trial. Acta Ophthalmol. 2010;88:e328–33.
Liu Y, Yang L, Yang G. Electro-acupuncture for treatment of dry eyes: clinical observation. Jilin J Tradit Chin Med. 2012;32:1275–6.
Guo M, Cui E, Li X, Zong L. Diverse needling methods for dry eye syndrome: a randomized controlled study. J Acupunct Tuina Sci. 2013;11:84–8.
Gao H, Zhao X, Ma G, Li H, Liu H. Acupuncture combined with pyonex for xerophthalmia. World J Acupunct Moxibustion. 2016;26:37–42.
Jing W, Xiaoyun M, Linping H. Needle embedding therapy on dry eye patients. J Changchun Univ Chin Med. 2016;32:1033–6.
Harris RE, Tian X, Williams DA, Tian TX, Cupps TR, Petzke F, et al. Treatment of fibromyalgia with formula acupuncture: investigation of needle placement, needle stimulation, and treatment frequency. J Altern Complement Med (New York, NY). 2005;11:663–71.
Smith CA, Zaslawski CJ, Zheng Z, Cobbin D, Cochrane S, Lenon GB, et al. Development of an instrument to assess the quality of acupuncture: results from a Delphi process. J Altern Complement Med (New York, NY). 2011;17:441–52.
Stapleton F, Alves M, Bunya VY, Jalbert I, Lekhanont K, Malet F, et al. TFOS DEWS II epidemiology report. Ocul Surf. 2017;15:334–65.
Gibson EJ, Stapleton F, Wolffsohn JS, Golebiowski B. Local synthesis of sex hormones: are there consequences for the ocular surface and dry eye? Br J Ophthalmol. 2017;101:1596–603.
Truong S, Cole N, Stapleton F, Golebiowski B. Sex hormones and the dry eye. Clin Exp Optom. 2014;97:324–36.
Ren Y, Yang X, Zhang Y, Wang Y, Li X. Effects and Mechanisms of acupuncture and moxibustion on reproductive endocrine function in male rats with partial androgen deficiency. Acupunct Med: J British Med Acupunct Soc. 2016;34:136–43.
Glenny AM, Altman DG, Song F, Sakarovitch C, Deeks JJ, D’Amico R, et al. Indirect comparisons of competing interventions. Health Technol Assess (Winch Eng). 2005;9:1–134. iii–iv
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.