Skip to main content

Table 3 Behavioral data collected at all time points. Total testing duration 2*60 minutes, without the fMRI tests and judgements/ratings. It comprises testing of all main EF components using mainly the WISC: Wechsler intelligence scale for children–5th Edition [89] and the KiTAP: Test of Attentional Performance for children [92]

From: Cognitive enrichment through art: a randomized controlled trial on the effect of music or visual arts group practice on cognitive and brain development of young children

COGNITIVE DOMAIN

FUNCTION

NAME OF THE TEST

BRIEF DESCRIPTION

REF.

Music abilities

Rhythm perception

Intermediate Measures of Music Audiation (IMMA)

Pattern comparison, judge if same or different in rhythm

RIGHT button for identical patterns, LEFT for different patterns

[87, 88]

Visuo-spatial abilities

1. Visuo-spatial reasoning & praxis

2. Problem solving

Cubes test (WISC-V)

Arranging physical pictured cubes in specific patterns according to a design

[89]

Working memory (fMRI)

Auditory tonal working memory

Pattern comparison (inspired by IMMA)

Compare two 3-note sinus tone patterns

1. Low load condition (3 identical notes): RIGHT button for identical patterns, LEFT for different patterns

2. High load condition (3 different notes): RIGHT button for identical patterns, LEFT for different patterns

Adapted from [87, 88]

Visual-spatial working memory

Visual n-back

6-case spatial matrix containing appealing monster figures - conditions: 0-back, 2-back

Right button for matched n-back trial l, LEFT button for unmatched n-back trial

[93]

Memory Systems

Short-term memory

Digit Span Forward (WISC-V)

Repeating series of digit sequences of increasing length aloud

[89]

Working memory: information manipulation

Digit Span Backward (WISC-V)

Repeating series of digit sequences of increasing length aloud backwards

[89]

Attention

Processing speed

"The Witch" (KiTAP)

Specific key for witch presented in window – respond as quickly and correctly as possible

[92]

Selective and sustained attention

Ucancellation (child-friendly version of d2 test)

Respond to upright dog (tail left), upside-down monkey (tail right) - Ignore similar distractors

[94, 95]

Auditory selective attention

Speech in noise perception

International Matrix Test

Participants repeat 5-word sentences heard through headphones: first without, then with a white noise background (right ear – left ear – both ears)

[90]

Inhibition

Response inhibition (motor inhibition)

Go/NoGo – "The Bat" (KiTAP)

Specific key for bat only - Ignore cat

[92]

Distractor inhibition (perceptual/cognitive inhibition)

Child-friendly Flanker Task

Left/Right arrow for center fish swimming direction - ignore surrounding fishes (congruent vs. in- congruent swimming direction), as quickly and correctly as possible

[96]

Cognitive control / flexibility (higher EF)

Perceptual switching (simple)

"The dragons' house" (KiTAP)

Match button press to dragon color as quickly and correctly as possible – 2 alternating colors

[92]

Rule switching (complex)

Dimensional Change Card Sort (DCCS)

Sort cards based on changing rules (color, shape), separately and mixed, as quickly and correctly as possible

[97]

Reasoning (higher EF)

Abstract/logical

Matrix reasoning (WISC-V)

Inspect incomplete matrix – choose missing piece from 5 options

[89]

Quantitative/analogical

Figure weight (WISC-V)

Inspect scale with missing weight – select balance option within time limit

[89]

Reasoning

Daily life functioning

Executive functions

BRIEF questionnaire

Daily living assessment of children’s executive functions

[98, 99]

Learning and progress

N/A

Multi-media materials

1. Videos (orchestra) – rating on ≠ Likert scales by independent judges

2. Photos and videos (visual arts) – rating on ≠ Likert scales by independent judges

 

Learning and progress

N/A

Teacher ratings (Likert scales)

Music: 1. pitch; 2. rhythm; 3. expression; 4. ensemble playing/singing; 5. motivation; 6. overall quality

Visual Arts: 1. graphic skill; 2. color management; 3. expression; 4. originality; 5. motivation; 6. overall quality

 

N/A

Homework

Use an online app to track homework

 

Others / Miscellaneous

N/A

Aerobic fitness

School gymnastic teachers report aerobic fitness on Likert scale

 

N/A

Demographic questionnaire

Questionnaire for parents (extensive, including extracurricular activities)

 

N/A

Academic results

Collection of all school grades

 

Emotion regulation

Emotion Regulation Checklist

French Version (ERC-vf)

French version of questionnaire concerning children; 24 questions on a 4-point Likert scale measuring 2 factors: emotion regulation & emotional lability

[85]

Emotion Regulation Questionnaire for Children & Adolescents (ERQ-CA)

French version of questionnaire for children (self-report); 20 questions on a 5-point Likert scale measuring 2 strategies: cognitive reappraisal and expressive suppression

[100]

Behavioral and emotional problems

Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ_Fra)

French version of questionnaire concerning children; 25 questions on a 3-point Likert scale measuring 3 factors: internalizing problems, externalizing problems, and prosocial tendencies

[84]