A practical approach to Sasang constitutional diagnosis using vocal features
© Jang et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2013
Received: 11 March 2013
Accepted: 30 October 2013
Published: 7 November 2013
Sasang constitutional medicine (SCM) is a type of tailored medicine that divides human beings into four Sasang constitutional (SC) types. Diagnosis of SC types is crucial to proper treatment in SCM. Voice characteristics have been used as an essential clue for diagnosing SC types. In the past, many studies tried to extract quantitative vocal features to make diagnosis models; however, these studies were flawed by limited data collected from one or a few sites, long recording time, and low accuracy. We propose a practical diagnosis model having only a few variables, which decreases model complexity. This in turn, makes our model appropriate for clinical applications.
A total of 2,341 participants’ voice recordings were used in making a SC classification model and to test the generalization ability of the model. Although the voice data consisted of five vowels and two repeated sentences per participant, we used only the sentence part for our study. A total of 21 features were extracted, and an advanced feature selection method—the least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO)—was applied to reduce the number of variables for classifier learning. A SC classification model was developed using multinomial logistic regression via LASSO.
We compared the proposed classification model to the previous study, which used both sentences and five vowels from the same patient’s group. The classification accuracies for the test set were 47.9% and 40.4% for male and female, respectively. Our result showed that the proposed method was superior to the previous study in that it required shorter voice recordings, is more applicable to practical use, and had better generalization performance.
We proposed a practical SC classification method and showed that our model having fewer variables outperformed the model having many variables in the generalization test. We attempted to reduce the number of variables in two ways: 1) the initial number of candidate features was decreased by considering shorter voice recording, and 2) LASSO was introduced for reducing model complexity. The proposed method is suitable for an actual clinical environment. Moreover, we expect it to yield more stable results because of the model’s simplicity.
KeywordsSasang constitution Diagnosis Voice Vocal feature
Sasang constitutional medicine (SCM) is a type of tailored, traditional Korean medicine. It divides human beings into four Sasang constitutional (SC) types—Tae-Yang (TY), Tae-Eum (TE), So-Yang (SY), So-Eum (SE)—according to their inherited characteristics, such as personality, appearance, susceptibility to particular diseases, and drug responses [1, 2]. Determining one’s SC type is important to ensure proper treatment is performed.
Voice characteristics in each constitutional type
talkative, impatient, clear, influential, loud, resonant
vigorous, clear, fruity, talkative, fast, hasty, illogical, impatient, high-pitched
regular, taciturn, thick, loud, resonant, grave, dignified
unstrained, artless, easy, sharp, not clear, not hoarse, still, calm, gentle, slow, low
Many attempts using computerized voice analysis methods for constitutional diagnosis have been made. Most studies excluded TY types since the number of TY types is too small to be analyzed statistically. As a result, SC diagnosis was treated as three-class classification problem. Various vocal features such as the pitch, frequency, formant, and energy of vocal signal were considered as quantitative features [5–7]. Park and Kim experimented with 71 people and found that there was a significant difference between SE and SY types in formant frequency and formant bandwidth . Kim et al. developed a voice analysis system called the Phonetic System for Sasang Constitution-2004 and used it to study voices characteristics of 231 adult males  and 217 adult females . Choi et al. used various features from a sentence utterance . A total of 195 adult males took part in their study. Kang et al. used 144 vocal features from 473 people pronouncing five vowels and two repeated sentences . They further developed a constitutional classification method  based on a support vector machine . In their study, 32.2% of the voice data were classified into three types with 79.8% accuracy. Although many studies have tried to find a relationship between vocal features and constitution, these studies used only a limited number of subjects, and as a result, have not been successfully applied to larger datasets. To reflect common aspects of many SCM experts, a larger set of data, collected from 23 different oriental clinics, was established in the study by Do et al. . More than 2,000 patients’ voice recordings were analyzed, and a classification model was proposed for the three SC types. The recording contents were five vowels and two repeated sentences, similar to the study by Kang et al. [12, 13].
In this paper, we use the same voice data as in the previous study , since this is the largest dataset containing patient SC types as proved by herbal remedy . Although the original voice data consists of five vowels and two repeated sentences recording, we only focus on the sentence part. It is important to note that both vowels and sentences data might be necessary for a full clinical examination including constitutional diagnosis, or diagnosis of a voice disorder  or vocal cord dysfunction . In practice, a short recording is required for practical use for the u-health system and mobile phone applications.
The idea behind our approach is that a sentence, rather than vowels, can effectively represent a person’s voice characteristics. If a constitutional diagnosis model generated from only a sentence performs similarly or better than a model using both vowel and a sentence data, it is more appropriate for practical use. We propose a diagnosis model that consists of fewer vocal feature variables than the previous study . The number of candidate feature variables is initially small since features from vowels are not considered. Moreover, feature selection based on the least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO)  was applied to reduce the number of variables in the classifier design. Experimental results show that the proposed method is not only practical, requiring shorter recording time and less variables to process, but also superior to the previous study in the generalization test.
Voice data acquisition
Voice data were collected from 23 oriental medical clinics. Patients were examined and their SC type was determined by SCM practitioners having more than five years of clinical experience. A more detailed procedure of data collection is described by Song et al. . We also collected face, body shape, and questionnaire data; however, only voice data were considered in this study.
Recording environment and procedure were strictly controlled by a standard operating procedure. Environmental noise was kept below 40 dB for low noise recording. To record, a Sound Blaster Live 24bit external soundcard and Sennheiser e-835 s microphone with a microphone stand were used. The distance between the patient and microphone was approximately 5 cm. Recordings were saved as wav files with a setting of mono 16bit integer and 44.1 kHz sampling frequency. Voice data consisted of five vowels (‘a,’ ‘e,’ ‘i,’ ‘o,’ and ‘u’) and two repeated sentences. The patient was asked to pronounce using their natural voice with the least amount of tension as possible. Each vowel was uttered at least 3 s. The sentence was uttered in the individual’s ordinary speed and tone. This process was approved by the Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine - Institutional Review Board (I-0910/02-001) and we obtained written informed consent from all study participants. In this paper, we excluded the vowel data and used only sentence data to diagnose a constitution.
Vocal feature extraction
Vocal features were extracted using a C++ program combined with the hidden Markov model toolkit . Vocal signals were divided into many windows based on the minimal time duration for feature extraction. The window size was 46.4 ms, which was mapped to 211 samples in 44.1 kHz sampling frequency. Neighboring windows were overlapped by 50%. We used 2n (n = 11) form for determining window size, since the exponential form does not require zero-padding in a fast Fourier transform .
Descriptions of vocal features
Average pitch and standard deviation
Average intensity and standard deviation
sMFCC0 ~ 12
13 Mel-frequency cepstral coefficients
Reading speed for a sentence
Log power ratio (60 ~ 240 Hz/240 ~ 960 Hz)
Log power ratio (240 ~ 960 Hz/960 ~ 3840 Hz)
Log power ratio (60 ~ 240 Hz/960 ~ 3840 Hz)
All feature values are based on the averaged output of the two sentence utterances, which were repeated recordings of the same sentence.
From the total number of 2,020 samples in the initial dataset, 55 cases involving individuals less than 15 years of age were excluded owing to their unstable acquisition of vocal measure. A total of 54 patients whose SC type was diagnosed as TY were also excluded because of its small sample size compared to the other three SC types. Since the measured vocal features, in general, showed non-linear fluctuation according to age, a process to reduce the effect of age was required. To eliminate the age effect to the vocal features, a standardization process, identical to that of Do et al.’s , was performed. All measured variables were standardized by using their moving averages and standard deviations derived from the samples within ±5 years of age for a specific age.
Prior to the moving average calculation, 11 outliers (five males and six females) were excluded by using the multivariate outlyingness measure and adjusted boxplot [24, 25]. Furthermore, 31 influential cases (13 males and 18 females) were identified by influence measures  such as difference in fits (DFFITS), hat values, standardized residuals, and Cook’s distance. The influence measures are calculated from a binary logistic regression model for one vs. others (e.g., TE group vs. non-TE group). The influential cases were excluded from the dataset since their absence significantly changes the estimated coefficients in the regression model.
The distribution SC for both train and test set according to age and gender
In the previous study conducted by Do et al., multinomial logistic regression (MLR) was applied to classify three SC types (TE, SE, and SY) using 88 vocal features. The classical MLR is a relatively good classifier for modeling the probability of membership of a class from the linear combination of the given features estimated by the ordinary least square (OLS) method. The OLS estimator, however, may be acquired with a large variance of coefficients and be impossible to solve if the dimension of explanatory features is too high or each of them is highly inter-correlated. These problems are referred to as over-fitting and multicollinearity, respectively. One well-known solutions to these problems is LASSO, which shrinks the variance of the coefficients and makes other coefficients zero .
As shown in Additional file 1 and Additional file 2, pairwise partial correlation coefficients for the obtained vocal features controlled for the age factor are significant in both male and female groups. Therefore, MLR via LASSO might be a better approach than OLS in terms of dealing with the multicollinearity problem and to acquire a stable and parsimonious model to classify SC types using vocal features.
where , β j is the j th element of the vector β, is the penalty function, and λ is the regularization parameter for controlling the model complexity. The penalty function of LASSO performs the shrinkage of some of the regression coefficients to zero when λ is sufficiently large.
To build the classification model for SC types, coefficients for 21 vocal features were initially estimated via LASSO using the glmnet package implemented in the R software. The tuning parameter λ was selected from the result of 10-fold cross validation using the mean absolute error (MAE) to measure the risk of loss. The decision rule is to choose the largest log (λ) within one standard error of the minimum so-called “one standard error” rule .
where are estimated regression coefficients via LASSO for each group corresponding to k. Specifically, is the intercept term of the classification model for each SC type and is the p × 1 coefficient vector with respect to the tuning parameter λ ’ as determined by the rule described above.
Classification model using MLR via LASSO
Result of estimated coefficients for vocal features for each SC type using LASSO
Final result of MLR for the classification of SC using age and score η estimated by LASSO
TE (l = 1)
SE (l = 2)
To make a fair comparison, we used a common set of samples between our study and the previous study conducted by Do et al. . Because the initial feature pool, outliers, and influential cases were different in both studies, the remaining sets of samples after data preprocessing were not identical. Therefore, an intersection of the data in both studies was required. A total of 1,692 samples (593 males and 1,099 females) were used as an intersection training set; note that in total, 1,869 samples (658 males and 1,211 females) were used to train the SC classification model. Similarly, 472 samples (165 males and 307 females) were used as an intersection test set.
Comparative results between the model in Do et al. and the proposed model via LASSO
Do et al.
Discussion and conclusions
In this study, a practical method for Sasang constitutional diagnosis was proposed. The proposed method was developed with a large number of training data and tested using data not included in the training set. The classification accuracies of the test results were 47.9% and 40.4% for male and female, respectively. We compared the diagnosis accuracy to a previous study using the same data. Although the proposed method had lower results for the training data, it obtained higher test results for both male and female test data. It should be noted that our approach had better generalization ability, even requiring shorter recording content, which is important for practical use.
In contrast to the previous study, which used 88 features from five vowels and one sentence, the proposed method used 21 features from the sentence only. We showed that our model having few variables outperforms one having many variables in a generalization test. A large number of variables usually cause over-fitting problems by increasing model complexity and as a result, the trained model tends to be sensitive to noise samples. We attempted to reduce the number of variables in two ways. First, the initial number of candidate features was decreased by considering only sentence information. Many of the features were extracted from five vowels in the previous study; however, they did not seem to play an important role in the diagnosis model.
Second, LASSO was introduced for reducing multicollinearity. Pairwise partial correlation coefficients in vocal features were examined to confirm multicollinearity. LASSO selected the proper numbers of variables so that not all of the 21 initial candidate features were used.
Although the diagnosis using voice does not have high accuracy by itself, it is helpful when used in conjunction with other diagnosis methods such as face, body shape, and a questionnaire. As of now, we are suffering from noisy features from the vowels; however, we still need to deal with the information from vowels and improve the diagnosis accuracy by combining the features from both vowels and sentence.
The proposed method is suitable in an actual clinical environment where patients might not pronounce a long recording content. Aged people especially have difficulty in uttering vowels for a long period of time. Our approach is also applicable to many voice-based diagnoses such as voice disorder detection, vocal cord dysfunction, and constitutional health diagnosis, expecting more stable results because of the simplicity of the model.
There are, however, some limitations of the proposed method. The classification model is trained by using a predefined sentence, and the same sentence must be pronounced during the test phase. If the recording content slightly changes during the test phase, the corresponding results are not acceptable. This can be problematic when extended to other languages. On the other hand, vowels have the advantage of being applied to other languages since vowels can be pronounced similarly among different languages. A short recording content may not represent patients’ vocal characteristics correctly. Although subjects are asked to pronounce in their ordinary tone without tension, some are nervous during the actual recording resulting in their recordings being different to their ordinary speech. An advanced voice analysis method, capable of dealing with more natural talking, is required for future research.
Sasang constitutional medicine
Least absolute shrinkage and selection operator
Mel-frequency cepstral coefficients
Difference in fits
Multinomial logistic regression
Ordinary least square
Mean absolute error.
This research was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Science, ICT & Future Planning (No.2006-2005173).
- Kim JY, Pham DD: Sasang constitutional medicine as a holistic tailored medicine. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2009, 6 (1): 11-19. 10.1093/ecam/nem090.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Song IB: An Introduction to Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 2005, Jimoondang: SeoulGoogle Scholar
- Lee J: Dongeuisusebowon-chogo. 1999, Cheongdam: SeoulGoogle Scholar
- Lee EJ, Sohn EH, Yoo JH, Kim JW, Kim KK, Kho BH, Song IB: The study of Sasangin’s face. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 2005, 17 (3): 55-68.Google Scholar
- Shin M, Kim D: A study on the correlation between sound characteristics and Sasang constitution by CSL. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 1999, 11 (1): 137-157.Google Scholar
- Yang S, Kim D: A study on the correlation between sound spectrogram and Sasang constitution. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 1996, 8 (2): 191-202.Google Scholar
- Kim D, Park S, Gun G: An objective study of Sasang constitution diagnosis by sound analysis. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 1998, 10 (1): 65-80.Google Scholar
- Park SJ, Kim DR: A study on the correlation between Sasang constitution and sound characteristics used harmonics and formant bandwidth. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 2004, 16 (1): 61-73.Google Scholar
- Kim DJ, Jung WK, Choi JW, Kim DR, Jeon JW: A study on the characteristics of the adult men sound as by Sasang constitution analyzed with PSSC-2004. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 2005, 17 (1): 67-83.Google Scholar
- Kim SH, Han DY, Youn JY, Kim DR, Jeon JW: A study on the characteristics of the Korea adult women sound as by Sasang constitution analysed with PSSC-2004. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 2005, 17 (1): 84-102.Google Scholar
- Choi JW, Song HS, Han DY, Cho SE: A study on the characteristics of the Korean adult male sound according to Sasang constitution using PSCC with a sentence. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 2006, 18 (3): 64-74.Google Scholar
- Kang JH, Yoo JH, Lee HJ, Kim JY: Automated speech analysis applied to Sasang constitution classification. Phonetics and Speech Sciences. 2009, 1 (3): 155-161.Google Scholar
- Kang JH, Do JH, Kim JY: Voice classification algorithm for Sasang constitution using support vector machine. J Sasang Constitutional Medicine. 2010, 22 (1): 17-25.Google Scholar
- Boser B, Guyon I, Vapnik V: A training algorithm for optimal margin classifiers. Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Workshop on Computational Learning Theory: 27–29 July 1992; Pittsburgh. 1992, New York: ACM, 144-152.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Do JH, Jang E, Ku B, Jang JS, Kim H, Kim JY: Development of an integrated Sasang constitution diagnosis method using face, body shape, voice, and questionnaire information. BMC Complement Altern Med. 2012, 12: 85-10.1186/1472-6882-12-85.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Song KH, Yu SG, Cha S, Kim JY: Association of the apolipoprotein A5 gene – 1131 T > C polymorphism with serum lipids in Korean subjects: impact of Sasang constitution. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2012, 2012: 598394-PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Godino-Llorente JI, Sáenz-Lechón N, Osma-Ruiz V, Aguilera-Navarro S, Gómez-Vilda P: An integrated tool for the diagnosis of voice disorders. Med Eng Phys. 2006, 28 (3): 276-289. 10.1016/j.medengphy.2005.04.014.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Zelcer S, Henri C, Tewfik TL, Mazer B: Multidimensional voice program analysis (MDVP) and the diagnosis of paediatric vocal cord dysfunction. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol. 2002, 88 (6): 601-608. 10.1016/S1081-1206(10)61892-3.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tibshirani RJ: Regression shrinkage and selection via LASSO. J the Royal Statistical Society B. 1996, 58 (1): 267-288.Google Scholar
- HTK speech recognition toolkit.http://htk.eng.cam.ac.uk,
- Proakis JG, Manolakis DG: Digital Signal Processing. 1996, New Jersey: Prentice HallGoogle Scholar
- Mel-frequency cepstrum.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mel-frequency_cepstrum,
- Hasan R, Jamil M, Rabbani G, Rahman S: Proceedings of the 3rd international conference on electrical & computer engineering: 28–30 december 2004. Speaker Identification Using Mel Frequency Cepstral Coefficients. 2004, Dhaka, Bangladesh, 565-568.Google Scholar
- Brys G, Hubert M, Rousseeuw PJ: A robustification of independent component analysis. J Chemometrics. 2005, 19 (5–7): 364-375.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hubert M, Vandervieren E: An adjusted boxplot for skewed distribution. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis. 2008, 52 (12): 5186-5201. 10.1016/j.csda.2007.11.008.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chatterjee S, Hadi AS: Regression Analysis. 2002, New York: John Wiley and SonsGoogle Scholar
- Friedman J, Hastie T, Tibshirani RJ: Regularization paths for generalized linear models via coordinate descent. J Statistical Software. 2010, 33 (1): 1-22.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6882/13/307/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.